Tax Drag and Alternative Investments: How Much of Your Return Do You Actually Keep?
Western Alternative Strategies — Insights
Tax Drag and Alternative Investments: How Much of Your Return Do You Actually Keep?
July 2026
Your client made 10% last year. They kept only 9%. That’s not a tax discussion. That’s a wealth discussion.
For taxable investors, the return that matters isn’t what a manager earns. It’s what remains after taxes are paid.
For a taxable investor in the top bracket, that gap — a full percentage point gone to tax drag — is a tangible number with consequences. Compounded over a decade, it represents a meaningful difference in wealth. And for most actively traded strategies, a 1% tax hit would be a good year.
Yet when alternative investments are evaluated, most conversations focus on gross returns, IRR, Sharpe ratios, drawdowns, and correlation statistics. What often gets overlooked is a much simpler question: How much of the return does the client actually keep?
For high-net-worth investors, trusts, and family offices, that question can be every bit as important as performance itself.
A strategy that earns 12% and retains 11.2% after tax may be more valuable than a strategy that earns 13% and retains 9.5%.
For Western’s Multi-Strategy Limited Partnership (MSLP) portfolio — our all-weather, evergreen, public market alternative fund — that question has a documented answer. And the results were notable.
Based on a multi-year review of MSLP’s partner tax documents covering 2020 through 2025, in most years of the review period, estimated annual tax drag remained below 1% of AUM for a high-bracket investor — a materially lower figure than the 1–2% annual tax drag commonly documented for actively managed taxable mutual funds.* We reference public mutual funds in this review for several reasons as they (i) are widely owned across high-net-worth portfolios, (ii) typically disclose after-tax returns, capital gain distributions, turnover ratios, and other tax-related metrics, and (iii) most private placements and many alternative investments typically provide far less standardized tax reporting, making it more difficult for advisors and investors to understand how much of a client’s return may be lost to tax drag.
Why After-Tax Returns Matter
For taxable investors, taxes are often the largest expense in the portfolio. Most alternative strategies are actively managed — active trading can generate short-term gains, ordinary income, and realized distributions that create meaningful tax liabilities each year. Many alternative strategies available to individual investors today were originally designed for institutions, which often place less emphasis on after-tax outcomes. As a result, tax efficiency is frequently treated as a secondary consideration rather than an integral part of portfolio construction.
Tax drag is the percentage of returns lost to annual income taxes, expressed as a percentage of assets under management (AUM). Actively managed taxable mutual funds have historically generated annual tax drag of 1% or more — and often meaningfully higher in strong distribution years — primarily because their structure requires them to distribute realized gains to shareholders each year, even if the fund has realized a negative gross return.* A fund generating 10% gross returns with 2% annual tax drag is effectively delivering 8% in real purchasing power.*
A 1% tax drag or less is a materially different outcome.
What the Data Shows: Tax-Efficiency in a Multi-Strategy Fund
The analysis focused on a straightforward question: What percentage of assets under management ultimately became taxable income each year? The answer was surprisingly low.
MSLP Taxable Income as a Percentage of AUM
| Year | Short-Term Taxable Income | Long-Term Taxable Income | Total Taxable Income |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 0.73% | 0.27% | 1.00% |
| 2021 | 1.16% | 1.34% | 2.50% |
| 2022 | 0.80% | 0.36% | 1.16% |
| 2023 | 1.38% | 0.69% | 2.07% |
| 2024 | 3.22% | 1.70% | 4.92% |
| 2025 | 3.22% | 5.29% | 8.51% |
In four of the six years reviewed, taxable income represented only approximately 1–2.5% of assets. The two most recent years, 2024 and 2025, reflect elevated realizations tied to strong performance. Higher returns produced higher taxable income. Even so, the after-tax retention rates in both years remained consistent relative to our observations of peer structures.
The pattern across the review period is consistent: the MSLP strategy generated returns that did not convert a disproportionate share of those returns into an immediate tax liability.
After-Tax Returns by Year: What a High-Bracket Investor Would Have Experienced (40% Blended Marginal Rate)
| Year | Total Taxable Income (% AUM) | Tax Drag (% AUM) |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 1.00% | 0.40% |
| 2021 | 2.50% | 1.00% |
| 2022 | 1.16% | 0.46% |
| 2023 | 2.07% | 0.83% |
| 2024 | 4.92% | 1.97% |
| 2025 | 8.51% | 3.40% |
In four of the six years reviewed, tax drag remained at or below 1% of assets for a high-income taxpayer. For an actively managed multi-strategy investment, that’s an unusual outcome.
Why Has Tax Drag Historically Been Low?
Several structural characteristics have contributed to the historical tax efficiency of MSLP observed in the review period. These characteristics are not incidental or random. Rather, they are a core element to the structure and design of the MSLP fund, knowing that tax efficiency and after-tax returns matter to our clients.
|
Section 1256 Treatment The strategy has historically utilized instruments eligible for Section 1256 treatment, which receive blended 60% long-term and 40% short-term capital gains treatment regardless of holding period — often producing a lower effective tax rate than pure short-term trading gains. |
Netting Across Strategies As a multi-strategy platform, gains generated in one strategy may be offset by losses generated elsewhere. That netting effect can reduce the amount of taxable income ultimately passed through to investors. |
|
Expense Pass-Through Unlike many traditional investment structures, certain expenses flow through to investors and may reduce taxable income. |
Deferral of Unrealized Gains A recurring difference between economic income and taxable income appeared throughout the review period — unrealized gains remaining within the structure rather than being immediately recognized for tax purposes. |
What This Means for High-Net-Worth Investors and Their Advisors
Most alternatives conversations focus on diversification, drawdown characteristics, and correlation to public markets. But for a client in a 40% marginal bracket, a strategy that earns 12% and retains 11.2% after tax is worth considerably more than a strategy that earns 13% and retains 9.5%.
The six-year review of MSLP’s partner tax documents suggests that tax efficiency and active management are not mutually exclusive. For advisors building portfolios for taxable clients, after-tax outcomes shouldn’t be an afterthought. They should be part of the investment process from the beginning.
The Bottom Line
When evaluating alternatives, don’t stop at performance. Ask a second question: How much of the return did investors actually keep? For taxable clients, that answer may be every bit as important as the return itself.
FAQs
What is tax drag, and why does it matter for alternative investments?
Tax drag is the percentage of investment returns lost annually to income taxes at the investor level. For taxable investors in high brackets, actively managed taxable mutual funds have historically generated annual tax costs of 1% or more.* Minimizing tax drag is especially important in alternatives, where active management can generate high-turnover income.
How is the MSLP platform structured to reduce taxable income?
Several structural features work together: consistent use of Section 1256 contracts (which receive favorable 60/40 long-term/short-term treatment), systematic netting of gains and losses across strategies, pass-through of deductible expenses at the investor level, and deferral of unrealized gains inside the LP structure.
What does “Section 1256 treatment” mean in plain terms?
Section 1256 contracts — which include certain futures and options instruments — are taxed at a blended rate: 60% of gains are automatically treated as long-term capital gains (lower rate) and 40% as short-term (higher rate), regardless of how long the position was held. This is more favorable than pure short-term treatment, which applies the full ordinary income rate.
How does MSLP compare to a taxable mutual fund on after-tax efficiency?
The mutual fund structure requires annual distribution of realized gains to shareholders, which has historically produced tax drag of 1% or more — and often higher in strong distribution years.* In most years of the multi-year partner tax review, estimated tax drag in MSLP remained below 1% of AUM at an illustrative 40% marginal rate — though that outcome varied, with meaningfully higher figures in 2024 and 2025. Past results are not indicative of future outcomes, and individual investor tax consequences will differ.*
Is this analysis relevant for trust accounts and family offices?
Yes. Trust accounts, taxable family office structures, and high-net-worth individuals with significant ordinary income are all beneficiaries of after-tax-focused portfolio construction. Investors in these structures should consult qualified tax counsel to evaluate how partnership-level tax characteristics interact with their specific situation, as outcomes will vary based on individual circumstances.
Does this constitute tax advice?
No. This content is informational and draws on a multi-year review of historical partner tax documents. Individual tax outcomes depend on a client’s specific circumstances, state of residence, entity type, and other factors. Clients and their advisors should consult qualified tax counsel before making allocation decisions based on tax considerations.
Is the Western MSLP Fund available on the iCapital Marketplace?
Yes. To access more information on MSLP and to invest through iCapital, visit icapital.com/westernalternativestrategies. Alternatively, qualified purchasers can learn more and invest directly with Western Alternative Strategies by contacting us here.
Explore More from Western
|
Our Solutions MSLP Fund Our all-weather, evergreen public market alternative fund — built for taxable investors who care about what they actually keep. |
Insight Are You Hedging the Wrong Risk? Our CIO on why most portfolios are built for the wrong storm — and what true tail risk protection looks like. |
News MSLP & Tail Risk on iCapital Western Alternative Strategies launches both funds on iCapital Marketplace, expanding access to institutional strategies. |
Western Alternative Strategies was built by fiduciaries who invest alongside their clients, which means after-tax outcomes are never an afterthought. If you’re evaluating alternatives for taxable portfolios, let’s schedule a conversation.
Source
*S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA After-Tax Scorecard Year-End 2024. Available at spglobal.com/spdji/en/spiva/article/spiva-after-tax-scorecard
Disclosures
The term “all-weather” is used broadly across the investment industry to describe portfolio strategies constructed with a range of market environments in mind. Its use does not guarantee positive performance under all conditions. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. This analysis draws on a multi-year review of historical partner tax documents; individual tax outcomes depend on a client’s specific circumstances, state of residence, entity type, and other factors. Clients and their advisors should consult qualified tax counsel before making allocation decisions based on tax considerations. Past results are not indicative of future outcomes. Western Alternative Strategies is a division of True North Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. This document is for informational purposes only and may be shared with the general public under Rule 506(c). Any offer to invest is made exclusively through the fund’s private placement memorandum or other authorized offering documents and is available only to verified accredited investors.