Skip to Content
WAS_4_3Imagery-15

Passive Investing Is an Active Decision: A Look Inside Index Construction

August 27, 2026

Western Alternative Strategies — White Paper

Two funds. Same market segment. Same investment style. An 8.7% difference in one-year returns. The gap wasn’t the market — it was the index behind each one.

Dallas, Texas  ·  August 2026    


The debate most investors are still having is active versus passive. We think that framing is out of date. Access full White Paper here.

Indexes have proliferated and grown considerably more complex. Each provider applies its own eligibility screens, style definitions, size segments, and reconstitution rules. Those choices are not neutral. They determine which companies you own and at what weight — and in concentrated markets, they can drive materially different outcomes for portfolios that look identical on paper.

Selecting a passive strategy should be an intentional active decision designed to meet client objectives and outcomes — not simply to mirror a predefined, rules-based index.

Two “Value” Funds, Two Very Different Portfolios

Consider two widely held US large-cap value ETFs. One tracks the Russell 1000 Value Index; the other tracks the S&P 500 Value Index. Both claim the same market segment and the same style. Only five of their top ten holdings overlap.

Russell 1000 Value (IWD) Weight S&P 500 Value (IVE) Weight
Amazon 5.9% Apple 7.3%
Apple 5.4% Amazon 3.8%
Microsoft 3.9% Intel 2.3%
Berkshire Hathaway Cl B 2.6% Exxon Mobil 2.0%
JPMorgan Chase 2.5% Walmart 1.7%
Top 10 total 27.8% Top 10 total 23.8%
Technology sector weight 18.6% Technology sector weight 20.6%

Source: BlackRock ETFs. As of June 30, 2026.

A few observations worth sitting with. Technology — conventionally a growth sector — is the highest-weighted sector in the S&P 500 Value Index and the second highest in the Russell 1000 Value Index. Amazon, a Magnificent 7 constituent, is the top or second-largest holding in both “value” indexes. Microsoft represents roughly 4% of the Russell 1000 Value Index.

The performance consequence over the trailing year was substantial:

26.9%

Russell 1000 Value ETF (IWD)
1-year return

18.1%

S&P 500 Value ETF (IVE)
1-year return

8.7%

Performance variance
Same segment, same style

Source: BlackRock ETFs. As of June 30, 2026. Periods over one year annualized.

Style Overlap: When the Same Stock Is Both Growth and Value

Russell assigns style as a continuum rather than a binary. A single stock can be classified 60% growth and 40% value, appearing in both indexes simultaneously. Apple and Microsoft each sit in the top ten of both the Russell 1000 Value and Russell 1000 Growth indexes at similar weights.

The top three positions in the Russell 1000 Value Index — Amazon, Apple, and Microsoft — together represent approximately 15% of the index. Before the most recent reconstitution, their combined exposure was modest.

Concentration is now an index design issue, not merely a market-cap effect. Growth indexes are the more extreme case — Nvidia alone represents roughly 14% of the Russell 1000 Growth Index, whose top ten holdings total 54.4%. That fund’s own prospectus classifies it as non-diversified.

Forced Equalization: Why a Value Index Keeps Absorbing Growth Stocks

Russell targets a 50/50 split of the parent index’s market capitalization between its growth and value benchmarks. Without that forced equalization, the growth index would be substantially larger than the value index.

The mechanical consequence: as capitalization concentrates in AI and technology names, stocks migrate into the value index to keep the two halves balanced. The gap between the number of holdings in the Russell 1000 Value Index and the Russell 1000 Growth Index now sits at a historically wide level — the last comparable period was the dot-com era. The value index may no longer be as representative of traditional value as its name suggests.

Reconstitution: Risk Profiles That Change Overnight

The June 2026 Russell reconstitution was among the more consequential in the provider’s history. Estimated Magnificent 7 weight changes:

Company Russell 1000 Growth Russell 1000 Value
Apple −4.79 +5.27
Amazon −4.08 +4.01
Microsoft −3.68 +3.88
Alphabet Class A +2.36 −2.03
Nvidia +1.11 0.00

Source: Jefferies Research, FTSE Russell, FactSet.

These changes reflect the index’s methodology — not any transformation in the underlying companies. Investors holding passive Russell strategies saw their risk profiles change overnight without taking any action themselves.

3% of the Weight, 25% of the Return

During the second quarter of 2026, Micron and Sandisk together represented 3% of the Russell 1000 Value Index’s weight but contributed 25% of its total return. At reconstitution, both were moved out of the value index and into the growth index — after that run-up had already occurred.

This is what a narrow market looks like from inside a passive vehicle. Two positions drove a quarter of the return, and then the methodology reassigned them.

The Value Index That Outperformed Because of Technology

Year-to-date through June 30, 2026, the Russell 1000 Value Index returned 16.2% against the Russell 1000 Growth Index at 5.3%. The intuitive explanation would be a rotation into traditional value sectors like Financials. The actual driver was Technology.

+89%

Russell 1000 Value — Technology sector
on a ~14% weight

+8%

Russell 1000 Growth — Technology sector
on a ~50% weight

Investors seeking traditional value exposure instead received high-beta momentum volatility — which happened to break in their favor this time. Style indexes are not always what they appear to be.

Emerging Markets: One Country, a 16.5% Gap

The same dynamic appears internationally, driven by something as basic as country classification. MSCI classifies South Korea and Poland as emerging markets. FTSE classifies both as developed.

Because South Korea is a large market with world-class semiconductor companies, its absence from the FTSE emerging markets index redistributes weight across Taiwan, China, India, and Brazil. South Korea represents 23.7% of the MSCI-based ETF and zero percent of the FTSE-based one.

44.6%

iShares MSCI EM ETF (EEM)
1-year return

28.1%

Vanguard FTSE EM ETF (VEE)
1-year return

16.5%

Performance variance
Driven by classification

Source: BlackRock and Vanguard ETFs. As of June 30, 2026. Periods over one year annualized.

IPO Inclusion: When You Own It Depends on Whose Index You Track

Providers also differ on how and when new listings enter an index. SpaceX — the largest IPO in history — illustrates the spread:

Provider Fast-track? Likely entry timing
S&P Dow Jones No More than 1 year after IPO
FTSE Russell Yes ~5 trading days after IPO
Nasdaq Yes ~15 trading days after IPO
MSCI Yes ~10 trading days after IPO

Source: Harbor Capital.

What This Means for Portfolio Construction

A passive strategy built to replicate an index may, in practice, represent a poorly defined portfolio. Indexes are designed to represent market segments. They are not designed around risk exposure or portfolio construction principles, and they were never intended to be.

The Passive Question

Index-centric. Which market segment should be represented? The answer accepts whatever structural biases the methodology carries.

The Western Question

Portfolio-centric. How should an investor’s capital be allocated? The answer is designed around the outcome, not the benchmark.

We evaluate both active and passive strategies through expected risk, return, diversification, quality, and valuation — seeking to construct portfolios purposefully designed to improve long-term outcomes rather than simply replicating indexes. Wealth managers and family offices should evaluate benchmarks as ecosystems, accounting for style overlap, sector exposure, and mega-cap concentration.

For more information on how Western evaluates passive and active strategies for client portfolios, or to request the full white paper, we’d welcome the conversation.

Contact Us →


Sources

FTSE Russell; S&P Dow Jones Indices; MSCI; BlackRock ETFs; Vanguard ETFs; Bloomberg; FactSet; MFS; Jefferies Research; Barrow Hanley; Harbor Capital.


Important Disclosure

The views expressed herein reflect our opinions as of the publication date and are subject to change without notice. This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security or adopt any particular investment strategy. References to indexes and ETFs are for illustrative purposes only. Indexes are unmanaged and cannot be invested in directly. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This material is intended solely for the use of the person to whom it has been provided and may not be reproduced or redistributed, in whole or in part, without the prior written consent of Western Alternative Strategies. © 2026 Western Alternative Strategies. All rights reserved.