Being Early Is Indistinguishable From Being Wrong
Western Alternative Strategies — CIO Perspective
Pessimism has always sounded more intelligent than optimism. The problem is that markets do not pay out on how intelligent a position sounds.
Dallas, Texas · September 28, 2026
Our Chief Investment Officer, Dhruv Maniktala, CFA®, was recently featured in Business Insider discussing how advisors navigate client anxiety in an environment with no shortage of things to worry about — artificial intelligence, sovereign debt, geopolitical conflict, energy prices. His comments get at something we think about constantly in portfolio construction.
The instinct to brace for catastrophe is not irrational. It is human. Behavioral researchers have long documented that losses register more powerfully than equivalent gains, and that a vivid downside scenario is far easier to picture than a gradual, uneventful decade of compounding. That wiring served our ancestors well. It serves portfolios considerably less well.
The Cost No One Accounts For
When investors position defensively, the conversation almost always centers on what they might avoid. Rarely does it address the other half of the equation: what the position costs while the feared event fails to arrive.
“I think doomerism exists, but if you are wrong for 5 years, even if you are ultimately right after that, you are so far behind that it’s impossible to catch up.”
— Dhruv Maniktala, CFA®, Chief Investment Officer · as quoted in Business Insider
That is the asymmetry worth sitting with. A defensive posture is not free. It carries an opportunity cost that compounds in the same direction, and at the same speed, as the returns it is designed to protect against losing.
An investor who steps aside in anticipation of a downturn does not simply pause. They forgo growth that the rest of the plan was built to assume. If the downturn arrives on schedule, the decision looks prescient. If it arrives several years late — which is the far more common outcome — the arithmetic rarely recovers, even when the original thesis eventually proves correct.
Being early, in practice, is indistinguishable from being wrong.
Neither Forecast Is the Point
The usual framing presents two options: stay fully invested and accept whatever comes, or move defensively and accept the drag. Both require a forecast. Both are wrong a meaningful share of the time.
We approach it differently. Rather than building a portfolio around the outcome we consider most likely, we build for the range of outcomes that are genuinely possible.
“All-weather means investing not for the most likely outcome, but for most potential outcomes.”
— Dhruv Maniktala, CFA®, Chief Investment Officer · as quoted in Business Insider
That distinction carries real consequences for how a portfolio is constructed. It means allocating deliberately to strategies that behave differently from one another — not as a hedge against a particular prediction, but as a structural feature that holds regardless of which scenario unfolds.
Forecast-Dependent
Positioning reflects a view about what happens next. The portfolio performs well if the view is right and poorly if it is wrong or early.
All-Weather
Positioning reflects the range of outcomes that are possible. The portfolio is designed to remain functional across more of them.
The Defensive Trade-Off
Reduces exposure to a feared event. Also reduces participation in everything else, for as long as the position is held.
The Structural Alternative
Explicit downside protection sized as an ongoing, predictable cost — so the investor can stay invested rather than stepping aside.
What This Looks Like in Practice
Western Alternative Strategies was built to give investors access to this kind of portfolio architecture. Our solutions use hedging and alternative assets with the goal of delivering returns that hold up across varied market environments, rather than depending on any single scenario to cooperate.
Those capabilities were originally developed for the clients of our affiliated wealth management firm. Demand from outside advisors led us to open them more broadly, and we now manage all-weather strategies on behalf of RIAs, financial advisors, and qualified investors.
The objective is not to eliminate risk, which no portfolio can do. It is to make the portfolio’s behavior less dependent on being right about the future — so that an investor who is genuinely worried about a specific scenario has a structural way to address it, without surrendering years of compounding in the process.
Not Optimism. Architecture.
There is a reasonable case for long-term optimism. Over sufficiently long horizons, broad equity markets have historically rewarded patience, and the forecasters predicting permanent decline have a poor track record.
But we would not ask any investor to hold a position on faith. The more useful question is not whether to be optimistic or pessimistic. It is whether a portfolio can remain intact across a wide enough range of outcomes that the investor is never forced into a decision driven by fear.
That is the work. It is less satisfying than a confident prediction, and considerably more durable.
Explore Further
To learn more about how Western builds all-weather strategies for advisors and qualified investors, we’d welcome the conversation.
Disclosures
Business Insider is an independent third-party publication. Western did not pay for this feature, and inclusion does not constitute an endorsement or guarantee of results. Quotations attributed to Dhruv Maniktala are sourced from Business Insider, September 27, 2026. The term “all-weather” is used broadly across the investment industry to describe portfolio strategies constructed with a range of market environments in mind. Its use does not guarantee positive performance under all conditions. Hedging and alternative strategies involve significant risks, including ongoing costs, potential losses during extended periods of market stability, and the possibility that protection may not be effective in all market conditions. There is no guarantee that any strategy will achieve its objectives, prevent losses, or result in higher returns. References to historical market behavior are for context only and are not indicative of future results. This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. This document may be shared with the general public under Rule 506(c). Any offer to invest is made exclusively through the fund’s private placement memorandum or other authorized offering documents and is available only to verified accredited investors. An investment in a Fund is speculative and involves a high degree of risk. All investments involve risk including the loss of principal. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Western Alternative Strategies is a division of True North Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser. As of September 2026.



